Skip to content
Vatican Observatory
  • About
    • Overview
    • Team
    • FAQ
  • Telescopes
    • Overview
    • Telescope Images
  • Latest
    • Overview
    • Resources
    • Press
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Research
    • Authors
      • FAQs
    • Newsletter
    • Tucson Meteor Cameras
  • Podcast
  • Education
    • Overview
    • Resource Center
    • Image Gallery
    • Summer School
    • Books
    • Software
    • Additional Resources
    • ACME
    • Ambassadors
  • Shop
  • Calendar
  • Support
    • Overview
    • Donate Now
    • Sacred Space Astronomy
      • View Content
    • Fr. Coyne Fundraiser
    • Bequests / Trusts
    • The Foundation
      • Newsletters
      • Annual Reports
  • Press
  • Specola Vaticana
  • Contact
    • Contact
  • About
    • Overview
    • Team
    • FAQ
  • Telescopes
    • Overview
    • Telescope Images
  • Latest
    • Overview
    • Resources
    • Press
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Research
    • Authors
      • FAQs
    • Newsletter
    • Tucson Meteor Cameras
  • Podcast
  • Education
    • Overview
    • Resource Center
    • Image Gallery
    • Summer School
    • Books
    • Software
    • Additional Resources
    • ACME
    • Ambassadors
  • Shop
  • Calendar
  • Support
    • Overview
    • Donate Now
    • Sacred Space Astronomy
      • View Content
    • Fr. Coyne Fundraiser
    • Bequests / Trusts
    • The Foundation
      • Newsletters
      • Annual Reports
  • Press
  • Specola Vaticana
  • Contact
    • Contact

Across the Universe: 36 Civilizations

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  28 Jul 2022  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

Share:
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via Email

This entry is part 200 of 201 in the series Across the Universe

How many Manhattans are there in the universe? This column first appeared in The Tablet in July, 2020

The headline caught my eye: “36 Intelligent Alien Races in our Galaxy, scientists say.” It also attracted a lot of rolled eyes from my fellow astronomers.

The work itself was actually perfectly reasonable. A recent [in 2020] paper in the Astrophysical Journal — which is the gold standard for the field — by Tom Westby and colleagues at the University of Nottingham revisited the “Drake Equation,” which provides an educated guess of how likely it is that other intelligences exist in our galaxy. They used new assumptions and updated data to motivate a new formulation of the problem. To give the University credit, its original press release merely claimed “Research sheds new light…” but that obviously wasn’t hot enough for the papers who ran the story.

Drake and his equation

The idea behind the “Drake Equation” is straightforward enough. It starts by using the way that mathematicians calculate odds. Say half the people walking through a door are wearing a hat, and half of everyone walking through that door carry a newspaper. Assuming there’s no connection per se between wearing a hat and reading the paper, one can multiply one half times one half and conclude that the odds are one in four of someone coming in with both a hat and a newspaper. Multiplying the odds of each condition gives you the overall probability that all the conditions are met.

One of the joys of being a Vatican astronomer is hanging out with cool folks like Jill Tarter and Frank Drake; this photo dates from 2016, when I began to serve on the science advisory board of the SETI institute.

Back in 1960, Frank Drake suggested we could estimate the likelihood of civilizations arising in the galaxy by multiplying the factors necessary for intelligent life. What fraction of the stars in our galaxy have planets? What fraction of the planets support life? What fraction of that life would be intelligent? And so on. His equation became a cornerstone in the Search for Extraterrestrial Life, or “SETI.” (Drake went on to help found the SETI Institute; I serve with him on its Science Advisory Board, where we recently celebrated his 90th birthday.)

Captain Hook

I can sympathize with Westby and his colleagues; they wanted to draw attention to their work with an attractive “hook”. Unfortunately their hook overwhelmed their real message. As a young scientist I once made the same mistake; back when I was a theorist I began a certain presentation with the deliberately outrageous comment that “you never understand anything in nature until you can model it on a computer.” The outrage I heard from those who distrusted computer models drowned out the point that I — and Westby, I suspect — was really trying to make.

It’s not the point of speculative mathematical models, be it my programs or the Drake Equation, to come up with definitive answers. (One point of scorn among my scientist friends about Westby’s work was the precise number of “36 civilizations” in the paper; the uncertainties in the calculation mean that of course you can’t possibly believe such a specific value.)

Model as examen

The real benefit of a model is that it makes you reflect, like an examen, on exactly which factors are important in the system you’re trying to understand. It is a way of making you state out loud the assumptions you are making; sort the essentials from the incidentals; and see what elements need more study to sharpen your understanding of the system.

Built into all this is an essential aspect of what science does. Science does not prove. Rather, it only aspires to provide the most probable description for how the universe works, while estimating just how far wrong that explanation might be. That’s a mathematical sort of humility… and humility is something that would benefit us all.

Share:
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via Email

Sacred Space Astronomy

The Vatican Observatory’s official digital community and online magazine.

Become a Member

Recent Posts

A tale of an unexpected comet

By Deirdre Kelleghan  |  1 Feb 2023  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

Skyward by David Levy – February 2023

By David Levy  |  1 Feb 2023  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

Detroit Stories Episode 46: ‘Faith and the Cosmos’ (PODCAST) – Detroit Catholic

By Robert Trembley  |  1 Feb 2023  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

From the Vatican Observatory Faith and Science Pages: Tradition and Today: Religion and Science, in Science in the Context of Human Culture II

By Faith and Science  |  1 Feb 2023

Archives

      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
      • December
      • November
      • August
      • June
      • March
      • January
      • November
      • October
      • December
      • November
      • April
      • May
      • January
      • December
      • September
      • May
      • March
      • December
      • November
      • February

More Posts in this Series:
"Across the Universe"

78  |  What Do We Lose When We Sacrifice Science?

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  27 May 2021  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

69  |  To err is human… to admit it, is science

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  25 Mar 2021  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

198  |  Across the Universe: Spiral Effects

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  20 May 2022  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

199  |  Across the Universe: Crowded Space

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  11 Jun 2022  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

201  |  Across the Universe: Story-telling

By Br. Guy Consolmagno  |  25 Aug 2022  |  Sacred Space Astronomy

Newsletter

Upcoming astronomical events, scientific breakthroughs, philosophical reflections… just a few reasons to subscribe to our newsletter!

  • *
Vatican Observatory
  • About
  • Telescopes
  • Latest
  • Podcast
  • Education
  • Shop
  • Calendar
  • Support
  • Press
  • Specola Vaticana
  • Contact
Privacy Policy  |   Cookie Policy  |   Disclosure Statement

Podcast:

  • Apple Podcasts Listen onApple Podcasts
  • Spotify Listen onSpotify
  • Google Podcasts Listen onGoogle Podcasts
  • Stitcher Listen onStitcher
  • Amazon Alexa Listen onAmazon Alexa
  • TuneIn Listen onTuneIn
Made by Longbeard